Me Too – in defence of men

October 29, 2017 — 2 Comments

The ‘#me too’ campaign has swept social media platforms since Harvey Weinstein’s face has blotched our screens and smeared newspaper print. Women – famous, infamous and those mere mortals who go about their daily business without ruffling the pages of gossip columns – have come out from under their perceived cloak of shame and have admitted to having suffered the egregious indignity of sexual abuse and violence.

And I admire them. Certainly those who have been, in some case irreparably, scarred by such encounters.

Tarana Burke, the brave woman who started the ‘me too’ campaign about ten years ago, having herself survived a terrible experience, says, “The spectrum of gender-based violence runs the gamut – no one’s experience shouldn’t be validated.” Her premis is that we should believe in the beauty of ‘me too’ and that empathy is at the heart of the campaign.

Empathy is a word tossed around a lot and is often muddled with sympathy. Empathy can only truly be felt by those who have had similar experiences, sympathy is what we feel for those people without in any way presuming to deeply understand their emotion. All of us though can work on being more empathetic.

I think I am one of the few fortunate women unable to write ‘me too’. The couple of instances of groping or lewd behaviour I have experienced, were so insignificant I refuse to give the perpetrators the satisfaction of an instant of my time, in either thought or print.

But abuse and violence are hard and fast words which immediately conjure horrific deeds – preface those words with ‘sexual’ and another layer of horror is added.

Then I started thinking about what constitutes sexual harassment. There are the whistlers, the brickie’s light-hearted comments shouted from scaffolding high above a street, the “you’re looking gorgeous today, luv” kind of observation from the flower seller at the entrance to the Tube. Things said that invariably brought a smile to my face on a grey morning or made me laugh in the sunshine.

Men, without doubt, have to be careful with what, and how, things are said. To know that no means no. Woman have to be careful not to stifle, or become so parsimonious and self-aware as to destroy the kind of banter that is part of human interactions. Where is the line drawn?

Innuendo, as well as blatant oogling, is a two-way street. Men pay for women to strip in girly bars, and give lap dances, and women giggle coyly at men strutting their stuff in a g-string at hen nights. The entertainers are, we hope, performing on their own volition but the acts themselves help smudge the lines of what is acceptable and what is not.

Then a week ago today, I started thinking about men. Not the ratbags who, in every level of society, have given cause for the ‘me too’ campaign but the decent, kind, loving men so many of us are fortunate enough to have in our lives.

Why did I start thinking about them?

Well, I fainted last Sunday. I was walking Clyde along the banks of Buffalo Bayou, on my own. I was happy. Then I was face down on a slab of concrete, coming to with the dog whining at my side and blood pouring from my face.

A couple of concerned men shouted from the bike path above to sit down, they were calling an ambulance. Ignoring them, crying and mopping my head with the hem of my skirt, I stumbled up the bank and staggered home to the man who would make it all better.

It was at the emergency centre that it started. My husband of nearly forty years was treated like a fist-throwing degenerate – he was brushed aside as he tried to help me walk to the examination room.

I was asked, “Are you safe at home?”

“Always,” I replied.

It was deemed my injury needed a plastic surgeon and so after having a CT scan I was loaded into an ambulance and taken to hospital. John followed in the car. He was again given the very cold shoulder despite me having explained what had happened. He was upset, not only by my injury but at the thought people believed him responsible. I sent him home to check on Clyde whose ablutions had been so rudely interrupted.

The plastic surgeon, I hope, has done a good job – it is too early to tell – but his manner was brusque, offhand – not an ounce of compassion. Possibly because he stitches up numerous violently abused women. I do accept it cannot be easy to separate the good from the bad and so understand the medical professionals’ dilemma, but neither should all men be made to feel a heel.

As I watch rich and powerful men stumble on their own hubris and women come out from behind their shame by hash tagging ‘me too’, I want to shout out to those legions of wonderful men who support their wives, their daughters, their girl friends, their partners, their sisters, their mothers – because not all men are bastards.

With a face full of stitches, I doubt I will ever be the subject of a cheerful whistle again, and I will miss that!

2 responses to Me Too – in defence of men

  1. 

    Gentle healing hugs to you and John. Something has been lost in translation in training EMS and medical personnel to spot abuse. It seems like our male support: husband, friend, or family are treated with suspicion no matter what our malady. During my last adventure to to ER with an anaphylactic reaction, my young son was accused by “professionals” of fighting with me provoking an anexity attack. Once I was was actually examined and confirmed it was anaphylaxis, no one apologized or showed him any empathy. My son saved my life that night.

    Like

  2. 

    I really appreciated your commentary. I too am fortunate not to be able to use #me too even though I grew up in a much different time when certain types of behavior that aren’t tolerated today were consider the norm.

    I agree with you 100% that things like wolf whistles from construction workers would bring a smile to my face – I never considered that harassment. And I’m sorry we live in a world where men in the office are not even allowed to tell a woman that she looks very pretty or that outfit really suits you. Like it or not, we are sexual beings. Men are not women and vice versa. Who would want to live like that? And yet it seems we are not allowed to acknowledge our sexual differences much less celebrate them in many settings. When I started work everyone hoped women might bring a different dynamic to the work place – softer, maybe more sympathetic. Instead we must be “little men” because we can’t just be women. I find it sad.

    And I particularly find it sad that people take what is a very serious issue to extremes. Not all men are molesters or abusers. Most men are caring individuals but all are now painted with the brush of doubt and suspicion. Social media can help bring awareness to problems, but it can create as many or more problems. People today seem to go to extremes – everything is black or white, left or right, right or wrong. There is no middle ground or any shade of grey. I don’t believe that is a recipe for success but I certainly don’t have the answer on how to make it better.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s